"If you look at the victories and failures of the civil rights movement and its litigation strategy in the court, I think where it succeeded was to vest formal rights in previously dispossessed peoples. So that I would now have the right to vote, I would now be able to sit at the lunch counter and order and as long as I could pay for it I’d be okay.
But the Supreme Court never ventured into the issues of redistribution of wealth and sort of more basic issues of political and economic justice in this society. And to that extent as radical as people tried to characterize the Warren court, it wasn’t that radical. It didn’t break free from the essential constraints that were placed by the founding fathers in the Constitution, at least as it’s been interpreted, and the Warren court interpreted it in the same way that generally the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties.
It says what the states can’t do to you, it says what the federal government can’t do to you, but it doesn’t say what the federal government or the state government must do on your behalf.
And that hasn’t shifted. One of the I think tragedies of the civil rights movement was because the civil rights movement became so court focused, I think that there was a tendency to lose track of the political and community organizing and activities on the ground that are able to put together the actual coalitions of power through which you bring about redistributed change and in some ways we still suffer from that."
take a wild guess at who said that in 2001. well, mr. president, it doesn't say what the state/federal government "must" do because it shouldn't. i'm not quite understanding what the most amazing orator in the world ever is saying in the second paragraph because he seems to recognise that the constraints the founding fathers so carefully crafted are "essential" to the continued liberty and freedom of the country for years and years to come, then says the constraints don't do enough to explain the government's role. the Warren court indeed provided America with essential shifts in social relations and social equality, at the time it was considered very radical--desegregating, giving more rights to the still-innocent (until proven guilty), upholding a right to privacy (the government cannot prohibit you from using contraceptives), and taking mandated prayer out of schools. and you know, that civil rights period drastically changed the face of America...in most ways for the better.
some seem to think that the removal of prayer from schools somehow affected the youth of America, but that's placing the blame in the wrong hands, isn't it? any religion is based on a personal relationship with the god. the court (and Constitution) was not saying you can't pray to yourself or with your family in your home or with friends who want to at recess, it was saying that a public school that takes public money and that a lot of the kids have no other choice of education than to attend this free school, does not have the right to promote any one establishment over another...hence my frustration with the same proponents of no prayer in schools denying students the right to learn both sides of the origins debate.
but i digress: back to the quote. he says that the Warren court wasn't radical enough in its view, because it stuck too closely to the "essential" constraints....er...wha? so then he says that the constraints of the founding fathers that create a charter of negative liberties doesn't define the government's role well enough. consider the mindset of the founding fathers: they were tired of being told what to do and tired of being ruled without proper representation. of course the document they drafted made sure to make sure no American administration or governmental body would ever tell its citizens what to do. the Constitution is a document full of limiting the government because the colonists were facing a government that had grossly overstepped its rights and limits. it is not a document written by a government to define what it will do for the people. it is a document written by (and for) the people to define what the government cannot do.
the president interprets the Constitution to enforce his idea of "social justice"...in another instance, he says: "I fear that reparations would be an excuse for some to say, 'We've paid our debt,' and to avoid the much harder work." so how does he intend to give effective and truly debt-erasing reparations? through legislative social justice that starts with an "empathetic" supreme court full of "perfect affirmative action babies" that believe the government and the American (non-minority) taxpayer has a 150+ year debt to pay...with interest. has anyone stopped to think that maybe if minorities weren't constantly told they are victims and owed something constantly in life, they might actually start to believe there is equality?
the most important thing to realise in social justice, and the most effective vehicle of that: affirmative action, is what Justice Thomas so aptly observed: as a successful and intelligent African-American man in the US, affirmative action taints everything he does. without affirmative action, there would be no doubt that he reached the supreme court based on his integrity, intelligence, and qualifications (as he did)--just as there would be no doubt that any successful minority reached a position via hard work, dedication, and intelligence. instead, the seed of doubt has been planted, and their success is "tainted". how does this advance minorities, again?
why isn't there more faith in the common good of the American people? this is in all areas! instead of relying on the charity of the American people, it's now assumed that the people must be taxed to death in order to get any good done...because government is now the solution, not the "problem" that ronald reagan identified it as. the American people and American institutions are, apparently, inherently racist and biased, therefore social justice is needed to ensure those evil Americans in the majority aren't constantly berating the minorities. instead of educating and changing the mindset of any racist Americans, the government simply makes them resent it by taxing them to death and giving promotions to minorities that did far worse on promotion exams than any white applicants (cough Ricci cough). the number one thing that angers me is the willingness of the American people to give up social responsibility and depend on the government for social justice. "That sort of thinking—that government should do it—is precisely what saps volunteerism and helps explain why both the Obamas' and the Bidens' charitable contributions are so pitiful." (US News) do what you can in your community, worry about yourself and your actions.
that US News op-ed has excellent insights into this 2001 interview quote and how it could affect America's future. "If Obama believes government can create rights, then that means he thinks governments can also take them away. " yup...terrified.
Comments